German knives are heavier and more forgiving while Japanese knives are lighter sharper and require more careful handling. However that same harder steel is.
While German blades are typically finished with a machine Japanese blades are almost always hand-honed and hand-refined.
Japanese vs german kitchen knives. Knives come in all shapes steel types angles hardness levels and so onbut the truth is that there are more similarities between Japanese and German knives than there are differences. I know its not an exciting revelation yet it simplifies understanding what sets them apart. Though there are always exceptions the main difference between Japanese and German blade finishes is that German knives are smoother while Japanese knives have more texture.
Japanese knives are also more likely to employ patterns such as a hand-pounded Damascus finish. German knives are heavier and more forgiving while Japanese knives are lighter sharper and require more careful handling. While these differences can be quite noticeable you should still get whichever type of knife appeals to you.
Having fun in the kitchen is just as important as all of these other characteristics. As a general rule Japanese knives do rust more easily than German knives although this difference is decreasing. Japanese knives historically focus on a high Carbon content whereas German knives focus on durability.
As a result pretty much any quality German knife will. German knives come in around 57 on the scale whereas Japanese knives are closer to 60 to 63. Harder Japanese knives will hold an edge better.
However that same harder steel is. While German blades are typically finished with a machine Japanese blades are almost always hand-honed and hand-refined. The edge of most Western-style blades is curved to allow for rocking cuts while Japanese blades are straighter in order to facilitate clean precise slices.
Ultimately German vs. Japanese is not that important especially as the gap between the styles of knives is diminishing. Some German knives are now sharpened to a more acute angle Mayer explains adding that new alloys have improved the durability of Japanese knives.
Mainly when you talk about kitchen knives you will hear about two knives which are very common- Japanese and German knives. Though there are many other types of knives too its safer to say that these two are the most pervasive so we can compare in Japanese VS German Knives. Ideally I would recommend having at least one good German and one good Japanese knife.
If I could only have one I would probably lean towards the Japanese knives for their versatility. As far as price there is not much difference. They all make knives in the 5000-10000 range up into the hand-made custom range of 100000 and up.
And there is a very simple reason for this. Traditionally German chef knives are ambidextrous while Japanese knives are not. Usually German knife edges are sharpened on both sides of the blade meaning the edge comes to a symmetrical peak allowing for right- or left-handed cuts without incident.
There are many differences in the features of German and the Japanese styles of knives and the basic difference lie in the type of steel used in making the blades. Other differences in the two most popular styles of knives include blade shape the weight of the knife and bevel etc. The angles on the German knives are usually about 20 degrees per side.
Japanese knives for the most part have no bolster and the tangs vary based on the knife maker. They are made using harder steel than their western counterparts and are rated around 60 to 61 on the Rockwell scale. Japanese knives tend to be thinner and sharper more useful for fine cuts on delicate fish.
Cutting heavier or tougher things however might be more of a challenge and can even damage more specialized knives. German knives will be thicker and therefore can take a lot more. The blade angles on the German knives are usually between 15-20 degrees per side.
Certain German brands like Wusthof however have a 14 degree angle per side except for their Asian style Santoku Nakiris and Chai Dos. Japanese knives more often than not have no bolster and the tangs vary between knife makers. Cooks generally agree that German-style stainless steel knife blades are hardier than Japanese-style blades.
Theres less concern about chipping or breaking the blade of a German-style knife. Its durability means you can use it for more cutting and chopping tasks. A Chef knife is basically an extension of a chefs arm.
This is the number one tool within a chefs arsenal so there is no wonder why they would want the best of the best. In choosing your knife there is only one comparison that stands out.